Categories: InternetWeb Design

W3C Markup Results: Some surprising finds

*Ok so either Live Writer is useless or I am a moron and can’t do posts with tables very well. I have quickly done screen shots of the info and posted that, if I get some time later I will redo it all*

So my last post was a bit of a rant about my Blog not validating and that I have decided to check some other sites around the Internet to see how popular developing websites with valid markup actually is.

My first lot of checks were Blogs from around the Internet, most of them are listed in Technorti’s Popular Blogs list however I have added several other ones that either I read frequently or I perceive to be quite big.

Every singe Blog that I checked that was in the Popular Technorati list failed the Validation test. I suppose blogs can argue that at least they are viewable properly through the RSS feeds.

The next list are websites mainly from the Alexa Top 500 Sites, however I have thrown a few in of my own.

And againt he majority of sites fail the validation. 2 sites that did pass that were interesting were www.msn.com and www.mininova.org. I can not believe Microsoft uses better markup than Google, and glad to see mininova one of the biggest bit torrent sites is leading the way in terms of valid markup.

Next are sites that promote accessibility and usability.

Interestingly Browsealoud advertise they conform to the W3C Web Content Accessibility Guidelines priority 1, 2, and 3 and say their pages have Valid HTML. Unless some glitch happened when I checked this claim is incorrect at the time of writing.

Next I checked some popular Newspapers and News sites.

Not a single site I checked passed the validation, with the BBC.co.uk having a staggering 1272 errors on the home page! It is also written in HTML 4.01 Transitional which is not very Web 2.0 of the BBC is it?

Next up I checked the Top 20 Universities based on the list at the Times Good University Guide

12 of the top 20 Universities have errors in their markup, quite shocking really considering our Universities are so big on accessibility etc. If we take a look at the worst offender Imperial College London with 590 errors They use Javascript Menues to navigate the site, though they do use NnScript to provide text links if you do not have Javascript. According the accessibility page the website conforms with WAI priority 1 and 2 checkpoints however I ran a check using WebXACT and the website fails all 3 Checkpoints with 2 errors in Priority 1, 3 in Priority 2 and 2 in Priority 3, with a further 44 warnings.

Finally I checked some Government and Organization sites.

Again majority of the sites failed. I am glad the Job Centre failed as from what I recall it is the worst and most non user friendly website ever. This also failed all 3 WAI priorities based on the check at WebXACT, I also could not see any accessibility information on the main page.

So in conclusion it would seem not many companies/organizations are too bothered about the W3C standards. I am not entirely sure how accessible all the above sites are, I do realise that there is a lot more to it than just validating your markup, however it was interesting to see how rare valid websites were.

James Smythe

Share
Published by
James Smythe

Recent Posts

Understanding Google PageSpeed Insights & Core Web Vitals – A green 90+ can still show as needing improvement in Search Console

Many website owners have breathed a sigh of relief that Google has delayed the algorithm…

5 months ago

Most Google searches generate no website traffic with zero-click searches

I briefly touched upon zero-click searches in a recent post about Google featured snippets. The…

7 months ago

Takedown bad Google My Business with a new tool from Google

Online reviews can make or break a business nowadays, which has unfortunately made reviews become…

7 months ago

Google featured snippets improve to normal levels following drop

Featured Snippets in Google are a blessing and a curse. One had they offer a…

7 months ago

LiteSpeed Cache + QUIC.cloud CDN vs WP Rocket + Cloudflare CDN PageSpeed Insights with Divi WordPress Theme

We all know website speed is important, ignoring Google; a slow website provides a terrible…

8 months ago

This website uses cookies.